Date: Mon, 12 Dec 2005 12:13:27 +0000 (GMT) From: amit agarwal <amit_agarr@yahoo.co.in> Subject: [dhcptest:00020] Re: Welcome to our (dhcptest ML) You are added automatically To: zhang <zhang@64translator.com> Cc: "dhcptest@tahi.org" <dhcptest@tahi.org> Message-Id: <20051212121327.6897.qmail@web8515.mail.in.yahoo.com> In-Reply-To: <200512120830.jBC8UEeM077584@bahamas.64translator.com> X-Mail-Count: 00020Hi zhang, Thanks a lot again.... The MAC address specified in the Nut.def was in capital, so it was unable to match both. Now is working fine and even the test case got passed. I am awaiting for ur reply for MRD test cases... Thanks a lot. Regards, Amit zhang <zhang@64translator.com> wrote: Hi amit, Thank you very much for your report. Now I cannot draw a conclusion from your description. Following words are just my deduction. I think there may be the problem of nut.def. For example, if using Linux OS, the Link0 will be set as following, Link0 eth0 aa:bb:cc:dd:ee:ff From your description, the reason may be that you use "LINK0" other than "Link0". And so you cannot get the variable of Link0_addr. Can you try to examine that and the path of nut.def ? Or else, you can send your nut.def to me. Thanks, Best regards, Zhang --------------------------------- Hi Zhang, I tried testing the "Use of upstream address when sends DHCP message" I even checked that the Nut.def file has proper MAC address assigned for LINK0. I even printed the value got for MAC address in get_nut_link_number() function in DHCPv6_common.pm file. Its the same value which i have assigned against LINK0 in Nut.def file. The test case is failing because its comparing this MAC adress with Link0_addr field. I have no idea from where he is getting the value for this variable. I tried printing this variable but could not print that. I am sending the messages from my client to the script on eth0. And i have set eth0's MAC address(of my client) to LINK0 in Nut.def file. Could you please look into the same and tell me what to do. Thanks, Regards, Amit zhang <zhang@64translator.com> wrote: Hi amit You question makes me think more about the test case. Thank you very much. Now I can reply to you. 1. Use of upstream address when sends DHCP message In RFC3633, " When a requesting router sends a DHCP message, it SHOULD be sent on the interface associated with the upstream router (ISP network). The upstream interface is typically determined by configuration." is decribed. ----I think this test is used to test the upstr! eam interface that the Requesting Router is using. It is a better way to use Interface MAC address to determine whose interface(Link) Requesting Router is using. I am very sorry, there is some inconsistence between the test script and the test specification. I will change the test specification to make them consistent. By the way, when you test , please set Nut.def file, and set Link0 as your upstream interface. The test will check MAC address and determine if It is Link0. It is the limitation. 2.About MRD test. ----I think my consideration is not enough to these test cases. I think they are BUGs. And I am considering how to fix them. I need some time! . After fixing, I will contact you. what about other test items? If you have other questions, I will be glad to discuss them with you. --------------------------------- Hi Zhang Thanks for your immediate response. I wil test with the .seq file you have sent. I have two more doubts. 1> There are two test saying "Use of upstream address when sends DHCP message". I wanted to know what exactly are these two test cases. Becauses these test cases are failing giving an error as "NUT Link MAC Address is 00:50:da:91:dd:ba Upstream Link number should be Link0 ." In the script he is comparing the MacAdrress with some variable, i could not understand that... Plz tell me what we need to do exactly. 2> Two test cases are to verify the MRD of Confirm message and Rebind message. What i am doing is, my DHCP client stops retransmitting when the next retransmission time exceeds MRD of that message. But the script stil waits for some more time and he compares two messages and say they are not same. Please clarify this doubt also... Thanks, Regards, Amit zhang <zhang@64translator.com> wrote: Hi, amit Thank you for your report. I am sure that this is a bug, and I have fixed it. We will fix this bug in next version.! I attach two files to this mail. You can use them to continue your test. If you find some other problems, please cont! act us. --------------------------------- Hi... I have implemented DHCPv6 I am testing my client and server using the tahi test scripts. I have a doubt in one of the client script. The script is : C_RFC3633_11_1_AdvWStatusCodeNoPrefixAvail.seq Here he says receiving advertisement with Status code "NoPrefixAvail" but what i found was he is sending advertisement with Status code "Success" but he in the reply for request message he sends Status code "NoPrefixAvail". But while sending the reply message he is sending wrong transaction ID. Can u plz clarify this... Thanks. Regards, Amit dhcptest-admin@tahi.org wrote: Cautio! n: If you reply this mail, your reply will be sent to the mailing list! post articles commands maintainer Welcome to our mailing list ! This mail contains the fundamental usage of the mailing list server. 1 How to use this server Plaese send commands in the mail body not subject to the address . The command syntax is as follows: help mget last:10 mp Plaese send the "help" to the address for help and server functions overview help to get general information on this list guide If you want to make a contact with the mailing list maintainer, please e-mail to dhcptest-admin@tahi.org ML server exists to descrease routine works by maintainers. Please try to use server functi! ons as could as possible. dhcptest@tahi.org Maintainer dhcptest-admin@tahi.org --------------------------------- Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner now. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner now. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner now. --------------------------------- --------------------------------- Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner now.20_2.html (attatchment)(tag is disabled)